Dante’s Relevance

In a most interesting article in a learned journal not known for its interesting articles, author Rod Dreher bemoans the fact that he didn’t read Dante’s Inferno — or the rest of the Divine Comedy — until he was in middle age (as was Dante himself).

     Midway along the journey of our life

      I woke to find myself in some dark woods,

      For I had wandered off from the straight path.

So begins Dante’s journey through Hell, Purgatory and into Paradise, as well as the story about a twenty-first century man who had also lost his way only to pick up Dante’s poem by accident and find himself captivated. What interested Dreher most were the chords struck by Dante that resound in today’s world and which should be heard by all college students, if not all who can read. And while it is sad to note that Dreher hadn’t read Dante’s poem until his mid-forties, it is refreshing to have him echo my conviction that the classics are relevant to today (which, indeed, is why they are regarded as “classics.”) But how can a poem written by a medieval Catholic speak to today’s students whose attention is entirely on themselves? That’s the question this article seeks to answer.

It is precisely the fixation of modern youth on themselves that one finds in the occupants of Dante’s Hell. To begin with, they all tell lies, and Dante is warned not to believe all he hears — which reminds me of Jameis Winston’s press conference where he said, with a straight face, “I’m not a ‘me’ person.” But more important, the nine circles of Dante’s Inferno are filled with thousands of passionate people who do not know how to love. The circles begin with love perverted, the love of a man for a woman that never rises above the level of lust, and ends, eight levels later, with those who either love only themselves or or betray those who love them, buried in ice up to their chins and condemned to remain frozen for eternity — as far from God’s love and warmth as possible. In between Dante finds those whose love degenerates into mere passion and is misdirected (they love money or fame, for example); they sin but fail to repent. And, indeed, it is the unwillingness of the sinners in Hell to repent that places them there instead of in Purgatory. As Dreher points out, “All the damned dwell in eternal punishment because they let their passions overrule their reason and were unrepentant.” Such as it is, their love was twisted and self-involved, and it dwarfed their reason which would, together with love properly felt,  have led them away from themselves and into the world of others who are also in need of love.

And thus we find the message that rings true today when folks are told to “let it all hang out.” As the author notes,

“This is countercultural, for we live in an individualistic, libertine, sensual culture in which satisfying desire is generally thought to be a primary good. . . . We live in a narcissistic, confessional culture in which speaking whatever is on your mind and in your heart is valorized as ‘honest’ and ‘courageous’ — just as calling lust love falsely ennobles it by dressing up egotism with fake moral grandeur. . .  All these damned souls suffer hellfire because they worshipped themselves and their own passions. In Dante egotism is the root of all evil.”

Furthermore, Dante’s sinners are unanimous in finding fault with others, never with themselves. They are very good at pointing fingers elsewhere and refusing to admit that theirs is the fault. The relevance of the ancient poem begins to become apparent.

Dreher takes the reader through several other circles, but in the end he notes, appropriately, that “Dante’s egoists suffering in Hell would be admired and even heroic figures in twenty-first century America” [Cue Jameis Winston, et al]. There is much for each of us to learn from this ancient poem written by a poet in his darkest hours — suffering exile from his family and from his beloved Florence as well. In the end, as Dreher concludes,

Dante shows us that you can just as easily go to Hell by loving good things in the wrong way as you can by loving the wrong things. It’s a subtle lesson, and a difficult lesson, and a lesson that is no less difficult to learn in the twenty-first century than it was in the fourteenth. But it’s still necessary to learn. Happy is the man who embraces this wisdom at any point in his life, but happier is the man who does so in his youth.”

It is sad that Dreher had to wait until his own mid-life crisis to read this remarkable poem. It is even sadder that very few will ever read it at all, though it is a bit of a stretch to think for a moment that even if today’s youth did read it they would see its relevance to their own lives. But it is certain that very few of them will read it at all if it is not required reading, which is even less likely in a culture that insists upon allowing everyone to find his or her own way — even at the risk of getting lost. Like Dante.

(Note: For those of us who don’t read Italian, I have found that John Ciardi’s translation is the most readable. Many are not.)




11 thoughts on “Dante’s Relevance

  1. Hugh, I have always loved the inventiveness of Dante’s Inferno and where he layered various sins – usury, e.g. I agree that we admire traits of people that would find themselves in the Inferno. Spin-doctoring is admired, but to me they are paid liars. People die because of their spin doctoring. Leaders are not held accountable for opinions they change without fanfare hoping we are not paying attention to ascertain their hypocrisy – the list is long. Politicians think we are beholden to them, when they lose sight they work for us. Great post and reference to Dante. BTG

  2. Clearly, Dante is well above the attention or moral capacity of most readers…high or low, without respect of persons. It really has nothing to do with Education, as most with the best Education have just as well ignored the Vision as has any among the rest, without intention. While, what is curious more, indeed, is that those who suffer most the pains and tribulations of human (designed) existence can better realize the insights of Dante, having never read his work. Often, as children, voicing the wisdom of the ages out of sheer desperation and long-suffering, with endurance…however ill-enjoyed. As the rocks cry-out.

    It’s a fascinating subject, which has long occupied my contemplation, investigations, instigation among my superiors and inspiration among my equals, or inferiors. Such is the established Jacob’s Ladder of our present existence, as it seems. Except, of course, for one takes occasion to remove themselves from the dynamic challenge, comfortable in their own delusions, illusions, or accomplished complicity in the way of things…such as the Ivory Tower may make, yes?

    Surely, you are not one of Them.

  3. Reblogged this on So, I Read This Book Today and commented:
    I hadn’t come across Hugh Curtler before, but when “musingsofanoldfart” pointed me in his direction, I found this post that makes a lot of sense to me. The Fart and I have been discussing how children are no longer encouraged to be unique, to strive for excellence while still retain a principled view of humanity and the worth of others. If you haven’t run across either of these blogs, check them out. There are a couple of smart, thoughtful bloggers!

  4. Well said. I’ve found that the classics are essential to have in your knapsack on the pilgrimage through life. All journeys need a map and journals of previous travellers to consult. Regards Thom.

  5. back on the equator, i am slowly catching up while reflecting on my trip to the states. i wasn’t surprised at all at the ‘readings’ when my brother in law took my blood pressure – three weeks into my visit.. the bp was high for me but probably average for most.. my pulse, however, at 8 in the morning was slightly above 100.. normally it’s in the 50s. i think most of that stress was due to ‘trying to keep my mouth shut’ as i traveled between loved ones while rarely having blissful moments of solitude.

    i am still trying to figure out if i should share or if i should remain quiet… some of my loved ones read my posts, and i do not want to bruise feelings!

    bottom line for me is that all have the intelligence but few are proactive, though they think they are (proactive.)

    still in guayaquil – day three in the search to locate lost baggage!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s