As Santayana famously said, “those who ignore history are doomed to repeat it.” But I would add that those who ignore history will find themselves lost in an increasiomghly confusing world. For all we know many of them would vote for a megalomaniac demagogue for president! Can you imagine??!!
I have referred in the past to the excellent group in Washington, D.C. — The American Council of Trustees and Alumni — that is acting as a watchdog over American higher education, drawing attention to the fact that the colleges and universities in this country (including most of the so-called “prestige” colleges) are failing their students. One of their favorite topics is the astonishing ignorance of American college students, across the country, regarding the history of their own country.
As we know, high schools no longer require a civics course, which would attack the problem a bit. But many do not require history either and the colleges that used to fill in those gaps are increasingly inclined to simply teach what the students want to learn rather than what they ought to learn. Call this a lack of confidence on the part of college faculties who lack conviction about what it is students ought to know. Or call it simply a lack of courage. But whatever we call it, it demonstrates why there is such wide-spread ignorance on the part of an electorale that has elevated a moron (and, some have said, a sociopath) to the position of one of the major candidates for president of this country — though one must note the exception of the students at Harvard in the Republican Club who recently voted (for the first time in Harvard’s history) not to endorse the Republican candidate for president! However, I stand by my generalization: this exception proves the rule, as they say.
In a recent publication by the A.C.T.A. we read about the depth of ignorance of which I speak:
“In surveys commissioned by the ACTA less than 20% of respondents could identify — in a multiple-choice survey — the effect of the Emancipation Proclamation. Little more than half could identify the purpose of the Federalist Papers. Only 23% could pick James Madison as the Father of the Constitution.
“American colleges and universities are failing their students. . .only 18% [ of those institutions] require students to take even one course in U.S. history or government. . . .
“Despite the colleges’ purported commitment to the noble ambition of training graduates ‘to be responsible and active participants in civic life’ or ‘civic leaders for our society,’ American history has disappeared not only from the schools’ general education curricula, but also from the requirements for history majors.”
The report goes on at some length. But you get the idea. People from other countries who must take citizenship tests to become citizens in this country and earn the right to vote are asked to know more than those born in this country who are simply assumed to know enough to pull the right handle in political elections, or color in the correct box. It is appalling. But it certainly helps to explain why there are so many in this country who are prepared to vote for Donald Trump and who hate Hillary Clinton because they have been told by those sitting on the political right that she is the devil incarnate. Without thinking they believe what they hear.
In a word, the failure of educators to take their responsibility seriously in helping students gain control of their own minds is at least partially responsible for the wide-spread ignorance in this country that has become gallingly apparent in recent months. But parents must also take responsibility for not demanding that the schools teach their kids what they need to know in order to become informed citizens of our democracy, and for insisting that their college-age kids avoid the Humanities and Arts (where they might learn to think). There’s plenty of blame to go around. But in the meantime, we are faced with a close presidential race when it ought to be a blowout!
Jack Cade is rubbing his hands together in glee!
Indeed he is!
(Old Bill knew a thing or two!)
We need people to not take things at face value and ask more questions, especially the one that starts with “why?” Too many take Trump at his word when the evidence is a mountain to the contrary. He has lied more than any presidential candidate since fact checkers started, but that is only in the campaign. An attorney who worked for Trump penned an op-ed piece begging people not to vote for him as Trump “lies all the time.”
Yet, in our country, if you say it with gusto and bravado, you can lie and it will be believed. Trump blatantly lied last night using the same proven lies, yet Matt Lauer did not call him on it. Yet, Clinton has had her imperfections shouted from the roof tops, building a caricature of her mistakes to run against. So, even the truth has a hard time sinking in.
As you have said, this is the line I have been preaching for some time: folks need to be taught how to think, not how to do specific tasks.
Hugh, we also have lost sight of the sense of right and wrong. The decline in civil discourse is a reason, the zero-sum politics is another and lack of veracity in news. Between the latter two, there is rationalization of poor words or action because your candidate did or said them, but condemnation if your opponent did or said them. Much of what Trump says is illegal, inane or immoral, yet people rationalize it. If Clinton said these things, her candidacy would have ended.
You’re right every time! We have abandoned civil discourse and in the process can no longer claim the moral high ground.
Great post as always, Hugh. But … one question … if they aren’t teaching history or government, what the sam heck ARE they teaching?
They teach their major courses and whatever the kiddies want them to teach. Most courses are job oriented, which is what they want because their parents try to steer their kids away from the Arts and Humanities: they are convinced those types of courses will not land their kids good jobs afterwards. But the evidence shows that those with a broad background actually end up making more money than those who take a narrow career-path and concentrate on those courses closely related to their majors.
Sigh. Makes one wonder … where are we headed?
I do wonder!
For what they are NOT teaching See Henry VI, Part 2, Act IV, Scene 7. Begin with line 2645!
Ditto for where we are headed!!
Thanks for reminding us! As I said above: old Bill knew a thing or two. Maybe even three!
Pingback: From Cradle To Old Man – Always A Brat | Filosofa's Word