Appropriate Punishment?

The saga of the scandal at Ohio State University involving the head football coach seems to have reached its predictable climax. You may recall that Urban Meyer, the head football coach, was suspended on August 1st when it was disclosed that he had failed to reprimand one of his favorite assistants who had been accused of domestic abuse years before and was eventually fired — but only after the matter had become public knowledge. The coach’s job, apparently, was to deal with the inappropriate behavior of one of his coaches in a timely manner and he failed to do so. The assistant coach in question — Zach Smith, one of Meyer’s favorites by all reports — had been guilty of domestic abuse and his wife had appealed to Meyer and his wife to intervene and protect her against her own husband. Meyer’s response was to do nothing except lie to the media about his knowledge of the affair and erase all of his text messages for the past year from his mobile phone.

The debate on television has been going on for several weeks now about the possible outcome of the discussions going on by a special committee set up to look into the allegations and to make recommendations about how to deal with the problem moving ahead. Speculation was that Meyer would be fired as he was ultimately responsible for the actions of his assistants, especially in the climate of college athletics where various forms of abuse seem to be a matter of course. But the decision, finally handed down, was a three game suspension without pay. The football program will not suffer and Buckeye fans breathed a sigh of relief. I heard it all the way out here in Minnesota where Ohio State has very few supporters.

The issue is one I have blogged about (endlessly some might say) involving corruption in collegiate athletics, especially at the Division I level. There have been cases of child abuse, cheating on a grand scale, rape, and now domestic abuse. All of these seem to flare up and then quietly disappear, swept under the rug for the most part, and things go back to semi-professional sports as usual. At the Division I level of the NCAA where college athletics rules, education takes a back seat. (I wanted to say it sucks hind teat, though that seems a bit vulgar. But appropriate, somehow.)

In the end we must conclude that these scandals are merely grist for the mill as far as the news media are concerned, something for the talking heads to discuss with worried expressions while committees are formed and high-paid officials meet to discuss what punishment might be appropriate. With rare exceptions, the punishment seems little more than a slap on the wrist. One wag, in commenting on Meyer’s punishment expressed his surprise that Meyer wasn’t merely suspended for half of the Spring practice game! Indeed, others have said that they knew Meyer would be slapped on the wrist and that the Ohio State University would not jeopardize its football program in this case. Such is our cynicism in these days of semi-professional sports in the palaces and country clubs that now comprise the athletics facilities in the larger universities. Let’s not rock the boat; its bringing in the dough!

Football and basketball at the Division I level do indeed bring millions of dollars into the coffers of the universities that make winning a habit. And that’s the bottom line: it’s all about profits. So while education as a whole has become a business it should not surprise us that sports at the most prestigious universities around the country would regard the preservation athletic teams as a top priority. After all, money is what it’s really all about.

The moral questions are hidden behind the rhetoric that nearly always comes out of the committee meetings where “punishment” is determined. The fact that a man who heads up a massive football program in a major university in effect supported his assistant in his determined effort to abuse his wife, and later lied about it, is ignored because the central question is how to make the whole thing go away. We have become, as a nation, unwilling or unable to face up to the hard moral issues that confront us daily because we think morality is a matter of choice, simply, a gossamer fiction of mere opinion not to be taken seriously. The possibility that those moral issues we choose to treat so lightly — or ignore completely — are the warp and woof of a civilized nation has somehow been lost in the shuffle.

In the meantime, millionaire Urban Meyer will enjoy his unpaid holiday for a few weeks and then get back to work — if, indeed he isn’t working the entire time behind the scenes. And Ohio State University will return to normal, concentrating its massive efforts on guaranteeing that its football team makes the collegiate playoffs at the end of the year because there is a great deal at stake. A great deal of money.


11 thoughts on “Appropriate Punishment?

  1. It really stinks and, again, as you and I both have written about so much, is emblematic of the really diseased state of major college sports. I wrote on a friend’s Facebook post about it that I’m not sure what the appropriate punishment is but three games is too light given Meyer’s role in essentially covering up the abuse and then flat-out lying this summer. He lied to the media; I’m not sure if he lied to his administration. If he did, in most places that’s ground for automatic firing. But this is college football at Ohio State, not a typical place.

    I suppose the school had to follow whatever steps were agreed to in Meyer’s contract for punishment as well as university procedures. But if a lenient punishment like this is in his contract, that’s another thing that speaks to the larger problem. We vest these coaches with too much power, and we bow down before it. And it does not seem to change things when one of these big-name coaches is fired for something egregious. A school simply hires another coach and the cycle continues.

    We’re complicit in it as fans, as taxpayers (when corruption occurs at public universities and if federal money is used in any form for scholarships). And … ah, you know the rest. Tree, telephone pole–the more it hollows out, the sooner it collapses.

  2. Hugh, this is a good tandem piece to the one I wrote today unlearned lessons. I started to include the Urban Meyer example, but limited Ohio State to the physician scandal with the wrestlers.

    Although the crime is limited to the DV abuse of one man, the story is similar to that of what Joe Paterno failed to do a at Penn State with his knowledge of Jerry Sandusky’s pedophilia. Both Paterno and Meyer are myopically focused on winning football games. Everything else is a distraction. Watching the HBO movie “Paterno” was very depressing. Why did you not do the right thing Joe? Urban? You both knew.


  3. As a non-sporty person, willingly ignorant of US sports (I went to one American Football match in Texas and heard ‘Bulgarian’ over the loudspeaker, apparently I should have heard ‘ball carrier’) I don’t know why I read this, but since I always find your pieces on morality interesting, did. I was sad to read the sorry story of Meyer and even sorrier to see what Keith said about cover up of a paedophile, but found myself depressingly unsurprised at public lying being so relatively casually dismissed – and of course it put me in mind of Trump. What a role model. Where will it all end?

  4. I completely agree with you when you talk about how scandals have been continuously popping up at the Division 1 level of athletics. It is sad to see but I also do agree that these scandals are easily swept under the rug. In a way these schools who have been caught in these situations have fairly good publicity coordinators because they are so successful in getting people to forget about these scandals. It just shows how publicity is such an important aspect for organizations. Although sometimes it is not for the right reasons, it is there to limit the consequences in a way and that is exactly what happened to Urban Meyer as you said. I also agree when you say that most organizations do not want to risk sacrificing their sports teams as that is what brings in most of their profits for the schools.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s